The success of any public welfare initiative depends not merely on its vision but also on the accuracy, preparedness and fairness with which it is implemented. In this context, the recent observation made by former Minister and senior BJP leader Choudhary Sukhnandan regarding the implementation of AgriStack in Jammu and Kashmir deserves appreciation.
His suggestion that the Government should complete Bandobast, update Jamabandis and undertake comprehensive settlement and re-settlement of revenue records before finalising the process of Farmers’ IDs is both timely and public-friendly. It reflects a practical understanding of the difficulties being faced by farmers and landowners because of outdated, incomplete and disputed land records.
Kudos to Choudhary Sukhnandan for raising an issue that directly concerns the common people, particularly the farming community. Equally, appreciation is due to Prime Minister Narendra Modi for promoting digital transformation in agriculture and placing technology at the centre of agricultural governance.
Addressing a press conference at the BJP headquarters in Trikuta Nagar, Jammu, on November 14, Choudhary welcomed the AgriStack initiative of the Government of India while stressing that the foundation of agricultural digitisation must be accurate and legally sustainable land records. He also highlighted pending mutations, inheritance cases, sale deeds, gift deeds and other lawful transfers, particularly those relating to the period after 2015–16.
This observation deserves serious consideration by the administration because it touches the very foundation of land ownership and farmers’ rights in Jammu and Kashmir.
Digitalisation cannot replace ground realities
AgriStack is an important step towards modernising India’s agricultural ecosystem. It aims to bring farmers, agricultural land information and related services into a more integrated digital framework. Under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Government of India has been pursuing technology-driven governance to improve transparency, efficiency and the delivery of benefits to citizens.
However, one important principle must never be overlooked: digital records are only as reliable as the original information entered into them.
If an old or incorrect revenue record is digitised without proper verification, the mistake does not disappear. Instead, it may acquire a digital identity and create further complications for generations. A wrong entry in a Jamabandi, an unrecorded inheritance mutation, an incorrect proprietary share or an outdated possession entry can directly affect a farmer’s eligibility, land-related entitlements and ability to access institutional facilities.
This is why the suggestion made by Choudhary Sukhnandan deserves attention beyond political considerations. It is a matter of public interest and administrative prudence.
The unfinished task of Bandobast and Jamabandi
Jammu and Kashmir has a long history of land settlement and revenue administration. In many villages, the existing settlement records are decades old. Agricultural practices, family structures, land ownership patterns and inheritance arrangements have changed considerably over time.
In several areas, discrepancies exist between the Jamabandi, Girdawari, mutations, cadastral maps and actual possession on the ground. Inherited properties may continue to appear in the names of deceased ancestors, while subsequent legal transfers and family partitions may not have been properly reflected in the revenue records.
The problem becomes more complicated when old maps do not correspond with present-day field realities.
The completion of Bandobast and preparation of updated Jamabandis are therefore not merely administrative exercises. They are essential instruments for protecting the legitimate rights of farmers and landowners.
Where fresh settlement has not been conducted for decades, the Government should identify such villages and prepare a phased programme for settlement and re-settlement.
Pending mutations require immediate attention
One of the most significant points raised by the former Minister concerns pending mutations, particularly those relating to inheritance, sale deeds, gift deeds and other lawful transfers.
A mutation is an important instrument for updating revenue records following a legally recognised change in ownership or rights. When an eligible mutation remains unattended for years, the consequences can extend to several generations.
For example, if a father has passed away and his legal heirs have not been incorporated into the revenue records, the subsequent process of inheritance, transfer, Farmer ID generation and verification may become complicated.
Similarly, a registered sale deed or gift deed should not remain disconnected from the relevant revenue record for an indefinite period.
The Revenue Department must therefore undertake a special drive to identify and dispose of pending mutations in accordance with law. Particular attention should be given to old inheritance cases, disputed entries and cases where the revenue record does not reflect legally established rights.
Patwaris must be part of the solution
Any meaningful reform of land records in Jammu and Kashmir must recognise the importance of grassroots revenue officials, particularly Patwaris.
A Patwari is the primary field-level functionary who deals with land records, cultivators, landowners, field verification, Girdawari and other essential revenue-related responsibilities. The Patwari is also familiar with village boundaries, local land particulars, traditional possession patterns and discrepancies that may not be immediately visible in digital databases.
Technology can process information, but field-level verification requires local knowledge, professional experience and accountability.
Therefore, the Government should strengthen the Patwari establishment with adequate manpower, modern equipment, laptops, reliable internet connectivity and proper training. The workload associated with AgriStack, digital crop surveys, SVAMITVA and routine revenue administration must also be assessed realistically.
Patwaris should be consulted while preparing the roadmap for correcting and updating revenue records. Their experience can help identify practical difficulties and prevent avoidable mistakes.
It would be unfair to make grassroots officials responsible for achieving digital targets without simultaneously providing them with the necessary infrastructure and administrative support.
A time-bound corrective action plan is needed
The suggestion made by Choudhary Sukhnandan should now be translated into concrete administrative action.
The Lieutenant Governor, Shri Manoj Sinha, and the Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir should consider directing the Revenue Department to prepare a comprehensive, time-bound action plan covering the following priorities:
Identify villages where fresh Bandobast or re-settlement has not been undertaken for decades.
Review and incorporate all eligible pending mutations in accordance with law.
Verify ownership, proprietary shares, inheritance and possession details.
Reconcile Jamabandis with cadastral maps, Girdawari and field realities.
Provide opportunities to landowners and farmers to report discrepancies and submit supporting documents.
Establish an effective mechanism for correcting errors before the finalisation of Farmers’ IDs.
Ensure that digital records remain legally reliable and that genuine disputes are decided by competent revenue authorities.
The process should be transparent, participatory and subject to proper verification. No genuine landowner or cultivator should suffer merely because an old administrative mistake has been carried forward into a new digital system.
A farmer-friendly vision deserves appreciation
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has repeatedly emphasised the importance of farmers’ welfare, technological advancement and transparent governance. AgriStack represents an important opportunity to connect agricultural development with digital infrastructure.
The initiative can become a powerful instrument for improving agricultural services, facilitating access to institutional credit and ensuring that eligible farmers receive the benefits intended for them.
But the foundation must be strong.
A Farmer ID should reflect genuine and verified information. Digital transformation should simplify the lives of farmers rather than create new rounds of administrative difficulties for them.
The observation of Choudhary Sukhnandan is therefore a welcome intervention. It demonstrates how elected representatives and public leaders can contribute constructively by highlighting practical concerns before a major government initiative reaches its final stage.
Kudos to Choudhary Sukhnandan for raising the voice of farmers and landowners. Kudos to Prime Minister Narendra Modi Ji for envisioning a technologically empowered agricultural India.
The need of the hour is to bring these two important dimensions together: the Prime Minister’s vision of digital agriculture and the practical realities of land administration in Jammu and Kashmir.
Let AgriStack become a milestone in agricultural reform, but let its foundation be accurate Jamabandis, verified mutations, reliable Bandobast and legally protected land rights.
Technology must empower the farmer, not complicate his relationship with his land.




