Srinagar: The High Court of J&K and Ladakh has acquitted three men convicted of assaulting forest officials and illegal tree felling in Baramulla, ruling that the prosecution had failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
Justice Shahzad Azeem set aside the November 2017 judgment of the Additional Sessions Judge, Sopore, which had sentenced an accused, Mohammad Latief Khan to 18 months’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 325 of the Ranbir Penal Code and three months under Section 6 of the J&K Forest Act, 1987.
Two co-accused had received three months’ simple imprisonment each under the Forest Act.
According to the prosecution, on June 20, 2006, Forest Guard Ghulam Qadir Lone and his helper Harvinder Singh were patrolling a compartment in Rafiabad when they saw people cutting a kail tree. When they objected, the accused allegedly attacked them.
Lone suffered grievous head and hand injuries, while Singh sustained simple injuries. An FIR was registered at Police Station Panzalla.
At trial, the prosecution examined only two of its five listed witnesses: Lone and the medical officer. Singh, the other injured official, and the Investigating Officer were never examined.
The High Court said the conviction rested “on a slippery foundation”. It noted that while a conviction can rest on a solitary injured witness, greater caution is needed when that witness is the complainant and the case lacks corroboration amid contradictions.
The court pointed to several gaps. Singh, described as the “natural and material witness”, was not examined, and no explanation was given.
The Investigating Officer’s absence was significant because the written complaint was never properly proved; Lone did not know who had written it, and recoveries such as the axe and timber went unexplained.
Lone’s testimony differed from the complaint. He said the accused fled and then returned to attack, a version that conflicts with the prosecution case.
He also gave differing accounts of whether one or two accused assaulted him.
Lone said the accused were named to him by Farooq Ahmad and also by a person named Khursheed. Neither was examined, and Farooq Ahmad did not appear in the charge-sheet.
The court said it confirmed injuries but did not establish who caused them or how.
Lone’s testimony was recorded nearly seven years after the incident.
The court invoked the Supreme Court’s ruling in Takhaji Hiraji v. Thakore Kubersing Chamansing (2001) to hold that withholding material witnesses warrants an adverse inference against the prosecution.
The court also faulted the trial court for relying on the accused’s failure to explain, under Section 342 of the CrPC, why the complainant would falsely implicate them.
Calling this “illegal, impermissible”, Justice Azeem said it amounted to a reversal of the burden of proof.
The provision only gives an accused the opportunity to explain evidence against him, and silence cannot fill gaps in a weak prosecution case, it said.




