• About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
Epaper
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
No Result
View All Result
Home BUSINESS

5-member NCLAT bench declines to reconsider decision on insolvency filing time frame

Press Trust of india by Press Trust of india
December 25, 2020
in BUSINESS
A A
0
5-member NCLAT bench declines to reconsider decision on insolvency filing time frame
FacebookTwitterWhatsapp

New Delhi: A five-member bench of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) has turned down a reference made by a three-member bench seeking reconsideration of an earlier decision related to deciding the time frame for initiating insolvency proceedings against a company.

In a 30-page order passed on Tuesday, the five-member bench headed by Acting Chairperson Justice Bansi Lal Bhat upheld that acceptability of debt entered in the balance sheet of a company will not amount to acknowledgment of debt for deciding the time frame for initiating insolvency proceedings.

More News

New multipolar world marked by sharp competition, transactional approach taking shape: Jaishankar

Cong stands with gig workers, considers them partners in progress: Rahul Gandhi

India aspires to lead emerging global economic order amid geopolitical shifts: VP Radhakrishnan

Load More

The five-member bench has termed the reference sent by the three-member bench in September for reconsideration of the decision in V Padmakumar’s case as a “misadventure” and “inappropriate”.

Observing that the three-member bench ventured to cross the red line, the bench in Tuesday’s order said that it was “judicial discipline for the referral bench to follow the judgment of the five-member bench” as a binding precedent.

In this order, the referral bench is the three-member bench.

“We are sad to note that the referral bench has overlooked all legal considerations. Such misadventures weaken the authority of law, dignity of institution as also shake people’s faith in rule of law,” the five-member bench said.

Further, the bench said, “we hope and trust that the honourable members of the referral bench would exhibit more serious attitude towards adherence of the binding judicial precedents and not venture to cross the red line”.

In a rare instance in September, the three-member bench had said that the five-member bench’s judgement passed in March this year was “contrary to settled law”.

A bench comprising Justice Jarat Kumar Jain, Balvinder Singh and V P Singh, had made the observations and had directed the registrar to place the “attached reference along with V Padmakumar’s case before the Acting Chairperson for constituting appropriate bench”.

The five-member bench’s ruling in March held that the balance sheet/ annual return of a corporate debtor cannot be treated to be an acknowledgement under Section 18 of the Limitation Act. It was related to the matter of V Padmakumar Vs Stressed Assets Stabilisation Fund.

As per Section 18, a fresh period of limitation shall be computed from the time when the acknowledgement was signed before the expiration of the prescribed period. The Limitation Act is also applicable for proceedings under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.

It implies that any insolvency plea filed over defaults that occurred over three years prior to the date of filing of the application are barred under Section 137 of the Code.

According to the order passed on Tuesday (December 22) by the five-member bench, a bench of co-equal strength can only express an opinion doubting the correctness of the view taken by the earlier bench of co-equal strength.

“Following… the judicial precedent of a bench of equal strength and of a larger bench as in the instant case, is a matter of judicial discipline,” the bench headed by Bhat said. Other members of the bench are the tribunal’s judicial members — Venugopal M and Anant Bijay Singh — and technical members — Kanthi Narahari and Shreesha Merla.

“It is not open to the referral bench to appreciate the judgment rendered by the earlier bench as if sitting in appeal to hold that the view is erroneous,” the bench said, adding that escaping of attention of the earlier bench as regards a binding judicial precedent or a patent error is of relevance but not evaluation of earlier judgment as if sitting in appeal.

“This brings us to consider the most painful aspect of the misadventure undertaken by the referral bench in making the reference which we have found to be incompetent. Judicial indiscipline creates uncertainty and impairs public faith in Rule of Law. Crossing the red line by disregarding the binding precedent results in making the legal proposition uncertain,” it said.

Previous Post

Trump vetoes annual defence bill; cites certain provisions as risk to national security

Next Post

Advisors to LG greet people on eve of Christmas

Press Trust of india

Press Trust of india

Related Posts

New multipolar world marked by sharp competition, transactional approach taking shape: Jaishankar

Those enjoying benefits of permanent membership clearly not in hurry to see UN reforms: Jaishankar
November 14, 2026

New Delhi:  A new multipolar world order marked by sharp competition, a growing number of autonomous decision-making centres and a...

Read moreDetails

Cong stands with gig workers, considers them partners in progress: Rahul Gandhi

NDA govt at Centre ‘crippled’; opposition dealt fatal blow to BJP: Rahul Gandhi
November 14, 2026

Hyderabad: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Saturday dedicated the gig workers' welfare legislation enacted by the Telangana government to the...

Read moreDetails

India aspires to lead emerging global economic order amid geopolitical shifts: VP Radhakrishnan

NDA’s soft-spoken Radhakrishnan elected Vice President
November 13, 2026

New Delhi: Vice President C P Radhakrishnan on Friday asserted that India aspires to play a leading role in the...

Read moreDetails

Supply shocks to weaken monetary policy effectiveness: CEA

Govt working overtime to cushion export sector from US tariffs: CEA Anantha Nageswaran
November 13, 2026

New Delhi: Chief Economic Advisor V Anantha Nageswaran on Friday said monetary policy tools such as interest rate adjustments may...

Read moreDetails

Indian economy has been ‘shining star’ in otherwise ‘gloomy world’: NITI Aayog VC

Indian economy has been ‘shining star’ in otherwise ‘gloomy world’: NITI Aayog VC
November 12, 2026

New Delhi: The Indian economy has been the "shining star" in an otherwise "gloomy world", as the country has maintained...

Read moreDetails

Retail inflation breaches RBI’s upper tolerance band at 6.09%; rate hike likely next month

Wholesale inflation hits three-month high of 0.53% in March
November 12, 2026

New Delhi: Retail inflation surged to 6.09 per cent in October, breaching the Reserve Bank's upper tolerance limit for the...

Read moreDetails
Next Post
Advisors to LG greet people on eve of Christmas

Advisors to LG greet people on eve of Christmas

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
E-Mailus: kashmirimages123@gmail.com

© 2025 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER

© 2025 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.