• About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
Saturday, November 14, 2026
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
Epaper
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
No Result
View All Result
Home NATION

Vikas Dubey’s killing raises handcuffing issue vis-a-vis SC guidelines on “inhuman” practice

Press Trust of india by Press Trust of india
July 11, 2020
in NATION
A A
0
Vikas Dubey’s killing raises handcuffing issue vis-a-vis SC guidelines on “inhuman” practice
FacebookTwitterWhatsapp

New Delhi:  The alleged encounter killing of dreaded gangster Vikas Dubey on Friday has kicked up dust over his not being apparently handcuffed by the police, against the backdrop of the Supreme Court’s disapproving the practice in various orders, calling it “inhuman, unreasonable, over harsh and arbitrary”.

The apex court has from time to time issued a slew of directives on the procedure to be followed while handcuffing an undertrial, maintaining that the insurance against escape does not compulsorily require handcuffing.

More News

Young, Henry wreck India to power NZ to 244-run win in 4th ODI

Centre extends ban on Zakir Naik’s IRF for 5 years; Amit Shah says his group promotes ‘venomous ideology’

Proof of allegations against Modi on my phone, which PM taps: Rahul

Load More

The police however has all along been supporting handcuffing at various judicial forums on the ground that the practice has been quite helpful in ensuring that a dreaded accused or convict does not flee the custody.

According to police, Dubey was killed after he tried to escape from the spot in Bhauti during his transit from Ujjain to Kanpur and their car met with accident.

It said the gangster snatched a pistol from one of the policemen injured in the accident and was shot when he opened fire while trying to flee, an account being questioned by opposition parties in Uttar Pradesh.

Six policemen, including two from the Special task Force, were hurt in the accident and the exchange of fire around 6 am, an official said.

With this incident, the debate over handcuffing criminals while taking them from one place to another has ensued once again.

The apex court in 1995 held that minimal freedom of movement cannot be cut down by application of handcuffs or other hoops.

It had categorically stated that handcuffing of prisoners without judicial consent was illegal.

The apex court had however said that in cases where the police or the jail authorities have well – grounded basis of drawing a strong inference that a particular prisoner is likely to jump jail or break out of the custody then the said prisoner be produced before the Magistrate concerned and a prayer for permission to handcuff the prisoner be made before the said judicial officer.

The magistrate may then consider the prayer and grant permission to handcuff the prisoner, it said.

“We clearly declare — and it shall be obeyed from the Inspector General of Police and Inspector General of Prisons to the escort constable and the jailwarder — that the rule, regarding a prisoner in transit prison house and Court house, is freedom from handcuffs and the exception, under conditions of judicial supervision we have indicated earlier will be restraints with irons to be justified before or after,” the apex court said.

In another case — Prem Shankar Shukla vs Delhi Administration, the top court in 1980 made important observations on he issue and said that there were other measures whereby an escort can keep safe custody of a “detenu without the indignity and cruelty implicit in handcuffs or other iron In contraptions”.

It said: “Handcuffing is prima facie inhuman and, therefore, unreasonable, is over harsh and at the first blush, arbitrary. Absent fair procedure and objective monitoring to inflict “irons” is to resort to zoological strategies repugnant to Article 21.

“Surely, the competing claims of securing the prisoner from fleeing and protecting his personality from barbarity have to be harmonized”.

The top court has observed that to prevent the escape of an undertrial is in public interest, reasonable, just and cannot, by itself be castigated.

“But to bind a man hand and foot, fetter his limbs with hoops of steel, shuffle him along in the streets and stand him for hours in the courts is to torture him, defile his dignity, vulgarise society and foul the soul of our Constitutional culture,” it said.

Referring to Articles 14 (Equality before law) and 19 (Freedoms of speech), the top court had S aid that when there is no compulsive need to fetter a person’s limbs “it is sadistic, capricious, despotic and demoralizing to humble a man by manacling him”.

“Such arbitrary conduct surely slaps Article 14 on the face. The animal freedom of movement, which even a detained is entitled to under Article 19, cannot be cut down cruelly by application of handcuffs or other hoops.

“lt will be unreasonable so to do unless the State is able to make out that no other practical way of forbidding escape is available, the prisoner being so dangerous and desperate and the circumstances so hostile to safe keeping,” it had said.

Previous Post

Preventing heart diseases naturally in the time of COVID-19 Pandemic

Next Post

Judicial commission probing 2014 Peshawar school attack submits report to Pak SC

Press Trust of india

Press Trust of india

Related Posts

Young, Henry wreck India to power NZ to 244-run win in 4th ODI

November 13, 2026

Mount Maunganui: Familiar foe Matt Henry cut open old wounds as India's much-vaunted batting line-up fell apart in the team's...

Read moreDetails

Centre extends ban on Zakir Naik’s IRF for 5 years; Amit Shah says his group promotes ‘venomous ideology’

HC refuses to grant relief to Zakir Naik
November 13, 2026

  New Delhi, Nov 13 (PTI) The Centre on Friday extended the ban on fugitive preacher Zakir Naik's Islamic Research...

Read moreDetails

Proof of allegations against Modi on my phone, which PM taps: Rahul

NDA govt at Centre ‘crippled’; opposition dealt fatal blow to BJP: Rahul Gandhi
November 13, 2026

New Delhi: Upping the ante over his debate dare to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Friday...

Read moreDetails

Rahul Gandhi ‘habitual liar’: BJP on Congress leader’s phone tapping allegation

Rahul Gandhi ‘habitual liar’: BJP on Congress leader’s phone tapping allegation
November 13, 2026

New Delhi:  The BJP on Friday hit out at Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi over his allegation of...

Read moreDetails

Phone tapping is a reality in India: Prashant Kishor on Rahul’s claims

November 13, 2026

Patna:  Jan Suraaj Party founder Prashant Kishor on Friday claimed that tapping of phones was a "reality" in the country,...

Read moreDetails

India seeks ‘positive’ and ‘forward-looking’ relationship with Bangladesh: MEA

November 13, 2026

New Delhi:  India on Friday said it desires a "positive, constructive and forward-looking" relationship with Bangladesh, remarks that came amid...

Read moreDetails
Next Post
Judicial commission probing 2014 Peshawar school attack submits report to Pak SC

Judicial commission probing 2014 Peshawar school attack submits report to Pak SC

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
E-Mailus: kashmirimages123@gmail.com

© 2025 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER

© 2025 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.