• TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER
Friday, July 4, 2025
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
Epaper
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
No Result
View All Result
Home NATION

CIC admonishes DoPT for ‘wrongly’ invoking exemption clause to deny info under RTI Act

Press Trust of india by Press Trust of india
July 8, 2019
in NATION
A A
0
CIC admonishes DoPT for ‘wrongly’ invoking exemption clause to deny info under RTI Act
FacebookTwitterWhatsapp

New Delhi, Jul 7 :  The CIC has rebuked the Department of Personnel and Training, the nodal ministry for Right to Information Act, for denying records related to appointment of Information Commissioners and framing of rules of the transparency law, saying it stifles “the very letter and spirit” of the legislation.

Information Commissioner DP Sinha lambasted the ministry for allegedly wrongly invoking Section 8(1)(i) to deny activist Commodore Lokesh Batra (Retd) information related to appointments of Information Commissioners and framing of RTI rules by the government.

Related posts

Nomination of 35 candidates rejected for first phase of J&K Assembly polls

Have decoded Bihar intensive revision to political parties: EC

July 3, 2025
Allegations against Adani group: JPC needed, Modi govt hiding facts, says Cong’s Khera

Special revision of electoral rolls: Cong asks EC not to act at behest of BJP

July 3, 2025

“It is ironic even further that the information that has been denied in the instant case pertaining to the appointment of Information Commissioners under the RTI Act, who are ordained with the statutory authority of securing the regime of transparency,” he said.

The Commission admonishes the then Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) for invoking Section 8(1)(i) of the RTI Act without assessing its applicability and the present CPIO is also warned against mindlessly endorsing the reply, Sinha said.

He directed that this order be placed before the Secretary of the Ministry to take note of “adverse findings” of the Commission.

Batra had filed two separate RTI applications seeking the information, but was refused on the grounds that these were Cabinet papers which cannot be disclosed before a final decision is arrived at.

However, the ministry had been disclosing records related to appointments of Information Commissioners during the UPA era even when the process was underway.

After he was denied the information, Batra had approached the Commission, the highest adjudicating body for RTI matters.

The Commission issued two separate orders after listening to him and the CPIO of the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT).

The CPIO, the officer responsible for answering the RTI applications, said the response was given by a different officer who was handling the position before him.

He also submitted that the process of appointment of Chief Information Commissioner and Information Commissioner was going on at the time.

The officer said that the documents sought by the appellant were to be submitted to the Search Committee (Committee of Secretaries) and subsequently to a Committee chaired by Prime Minister and consisting of Leader of Opposition and a Union Cabinet Minister.

The ministry also refused to disclose the file related to framing of 2017 rules of the RTI, saying it was “under process”.

Rejecting the arguments in both cases, Sinha said the submissions of the CPIO appear incoherent and do not convey any substantial justification for invoking Section 8(1)(i) of RTI Act.

“The conduct of the then CPIO as well as the present CPIO reflects on their sheer evasiveness and non-application of mind in dealing with the instant RTI application,” he noted.

Sinha agreed with Batra that “this kind of conduct amounts to stonewalling RTI Applications and stifling the very letter and spirit of RTI Act weighs in”.

“Complainant has rightly pointed out that such mindless application of exemptions of RTI Act to deny information by the CPIO(s) of DoPT casts serious aspersions on the commitment of the nodal agency of RTI to the tenets of probity and transparency,” Sinha said.

By resorting to such unwarranted opacity, the DoPT is setting a bad example for other public authorities and at the same time is discrediting its own footing as the nodal agency for implementation of RTI Act, he said.

Previous Post

  Chairman, Director IIM Jammu called on Ganai

Next Post

At least 12 dead in Taliban blast in Afghan city

Press Trust of india

Press Trust of india

Next Post
At least 12 dead in Taliban blast in Afghan city

At least 12 dead in Taliban blast in Afghan city

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ePaper

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
E-Mailus: [email protected]

© 2024 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER

© 2024 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.