Press Trust of india

SC transfers Kathua gangrape case to Pathankot

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

Says:Fear and fair trial contradictory, can’t be allowed to co-exist; no need to handover investigation to any other agency

New Delhi, May 07: The Supreme Court today transferred the trial in the Kathua gangrape and murder case of an eight-year-old girl from Jammu and Kashmir to Pathankot in Punjab, but refrained from handing over the probe to CBI saying there was no need as the investigation has been conducted and the charge-sheet filed.

The apex court, which ordered day-to-day “in-camera” trial in the case, said there was a need to shift the trial outside the state as “fear and fair trial” were contradictory and “cannot be allowed to co-exist.”

A bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra also vacated the stay granted by it earlier on the trial in the case and said it should be fast-tracked to ensure that there was no delay in adjudication of the matter.

The bench, also comprising Justices D Y Chandrachud and Indu Malhotra, allowed the Jammu and Kashmir government to appoint a special public prosecutor (SPP) to conduct the trial and ordered continuation of security provided to the victim’s family members, a family friend and the lawyer representing them.

It also said that trial would be carried out in accordance with the provisions of Ranbir Penal Code, which is applicable in Jammu and Kashmir, and asked the state to get statements of witnesses and records of the case translated from Urdu to English.

The bench listed the matter for further hearing on July 09.

While the victim’s father had sought transfer of the trial out of Kathua, preferably to Chandigarh, and reposed faith in the probe by the J and K police, the two accused had moved the court with a diametrically opposite prayer seeking trial at Kathua and probe by the CBI.

Emphasising that the trial must be fair to both the victim’s family and the accused, the bench directed the state to facilitate transportation and accommodation to the victim’s family, lawyers and witnesses from Kathua to Pathankot.

The apex court, while asking the district and sessions judge at Pathankot to personally undertake the trial proceedings and not assign it to other session judges, said it would monitor the progress of trial in the case and no other courts should entertain any other plea related to the matter.

“Needless to say, a fair trial is a sacrosanct principle under Article 21 of the Constitution and ‘fair trial’ means fair to the accused persons, as well as to the victims of the crime. In the instant case, direct victims are the family members of the deceased, although ultimate collective is the victim of such crime,” the bench said.

“Fair trial commands that there has to be free atmosphere where the victims, the accused and the witnesses feel safe. They must not suffer from any kind of phobia while attending the court. Fear and fair trial are contradictory in terms and they cannot be allowed to co-exist,” the court said.

“Concept of ‘fair trial’, needs no special emphasis and it takes within its sweep the conception of a speedy trial and the speedy trial meets its purpose when the trials are held without grant of adjournment as provided under the provisions contained in section 309 CrPC,” it said.

The decision to transfer the trial from Kathua in Jammu to Pathankot came after deliberations during which the names of several districts in the state —  Udhampur, Jammu, Ramban, Sambha, Reasi, Poonch, Rajouri and Doda — were considered.

Initially, there was a consensus on transferring the trial to Ramban but the counsel appearing for two accused objected to it saying that Ramban was far from Kathua and hit by “terrorism” and there was also a “polarisation of the community”.

At the outset, senior advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for the victim’s father, said a charge-sheet has been filed in the case and further investigation was going on.

Jaising, while contending that they were satisfied with the probe conducted by the Crime Branch of the J&K Police, said entire case was given a “political colour” by the accused despite the fact that it was a matter relating to rape and murder of a minor girl.

Senior advocate Gopal Subramanium, appearing for Jammu and Kashmir, said the police has already filed a detailed charge-sheet and further probe was being carried out and the question was about having an atmosphere to hold a fair trial in Kathua.

“We would like a fair trial to take place. Further investigation is going on at a rapid pace,” he said, adding that the police opposed the transfer of case outside the state.

“We undertake to give protection to all the counsel in the case also. The investigation conducted was sound one and it was done in record time,” he said and suggested that the trial could be transferred to Jammu, Sambha, Udhampur or Sambha.

Senior counsel Meenakshi Arora, appearing for the accused, alleged that the probe was “botched up” and hence a fair trial cannot be expected.

The bench then observed “after the investigation is conducted and charge-sheet is filed, why should there be any need to transfer investigation to other agency?”

The victim, an eight-year-old girl from a minority nomadic community, had disappeared from near her home in a village close to Kathua in the Jammu region on January 10. Her body was found in the same area a week later.

The state police has filed the main charge sheet against seven persons and a separate charge sheet against a juvenile in a court in Kathua district.

 

It will boost morale of state police: Mehbooba

Srinagar, May 07: Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti today said the Supreme Court decision to shift the trial of the Kathua gangrape and murder case to Pathankot would boost the morale of the state police, which had left “no stone unturned” to ensure that the eight-year-old’s family gets justice.

The apex court today directed that the trial of the gangrape and murder of the child,  which had led to nationwide outrage, be moved to Pathankot in neighbouring Punjab.

“I welcome today’s decision by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Kathua case. This will go a long way to boost the morale of our @JmuKmrPolice force who in the face of great adversity have left no stone unturned to ensure that the deceased’s family gets justice,” Mehbooba said in a tweet.

 Victim’s father welcomes; says he has full faith in judiciary

Jammu, May 07 (PTI) The father of an eight-year-old girl who was gang-raped and killed in Kathua district today welcomed the Supreme Court decision to transfer the case to Pathankot and said he has full faith in the judiciary.

The grieving father, belonging to a minority nomadic Bakerwal community which earns its livelihood by raising cattle, also said he has full faith in the government.

“We only want justice…I have full faith in the judiciary and the government,” the father said over the phone from Ramban district where he is camping along with other members of his family.

“We don’t favour a CBI probe either. We do not know CBI and our only desire is that justice is done…,” he said.

The community is moving on foot to the higher reaches of Kashmir in search of greener pastures and has set up temporary shelter in Ramban along the Jammu-Srinagar national highway due to inclement weather.

The father said yesterday that he has devoted his life to ensure that justice is done to his daughter.

“I am satisfied with police investigation and will not rest till justice is done in the case. I want the accused to be given exemplary punishment for their brutality,” he said.

Meanwhile, Ankur Sharma, who is defending the eight accused arrested by the Crime Branch, said, “We will file fresh writ petition in the Supreme Court for a CBI probe in a few days.”

“The CBI demand has not been rejected by Supreme Court. Only the case has been fast-tracked (to be heard on day to day basis) and transferred to Pathankot,” Sharma said.

 

CJM court fixes May 22 as next date of hearing

Kathua, May 07  (PTI)  A court today posted for May 22 the hearing in the case of the juvenile accused in the rape-and-murder of an eight-year-old girl in Kathua.

Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) A S Langeh fixed the hearing for May 22.

Earlier on April 25,  the juvenile presented himself before the court amid heavy security.

CJM Langeh had then asked the juvenile whether he had received copies of the charge-sheet from the Crime Branch, to which he replied in the affirmative.

The CJM court had dismissed the bail plea of the accused juvenile.

The counsel for the accused had moved the court for his bail soon after the Crime Branch had filed its charge-sheet against him and seven others allegedly involved in the rape and murder case. The juvenile accused had sought the bail on the ground of his age.

According to the Crime Branch charge-sheet, the juvenile had allegedly played a key role in the crime.

A sub-inspector and a head constable too have been apprehended on charges of destroying crucial evidence in the case to save the culprits. The body of the girl was recovered from a forest on January 17, a week after she had gone missing in the forest area.

The Jammu and Kashmir government had handed over the case to the Crime Branch, which had formed a special investigation team to probe the rape-cum-murder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *