Srinagar: The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has upheld a Rs 2.5 lakh penalty imposed on Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) for energising a Pulwama fuel station before it received final access permission from the highway authorities.
The court also ordered the district administration to clear encroachments blocking the outlet’s access road.
Justice Sanjay Dhar delivered the ruling on a petition by Zahida Mushtaq, who runs “Fatima Filling Station” at Letpora, Pampore, on behalf of IOCL.
She challenged a July 28, 2025 communication from the National Highway Authority directing IOCL to pay the penalty and de-energise the outlet until final clearance.
Mushtaq argued that final access permission was delayed only because of encroachments on National Highway land, which the authorities had failed to remove. She said she should not be penalised for that.
The court agreed the delay was not her fault but held that this did not excuse operating the pump.
Under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways’ June 2020 guidelines, which the court called mandatory, a provisional permission does not allow a fuel station to be energised. Only a regular access permission does, and energising without it attracts the Rs 2.5 lakh penalty.
The court said the petitioner’s inability to build the access road could justify seeking an extension of the provisional permission, but it could never justify energising the pump.
The court also rejected a preliminary objection from Zaffar Ahmad Lone, a neighbour who had been added as a respondent.
Lone argued that Mushtaq had hidden an earlier High Court order from August 2025, passed on his own petition, which told the Pulwama District Magistrate to verify all her NOCs.
The court said the earlier petition was not a material fact for the reliefs sought here. It added, however, that she should have disclosed it when she obtained an interim order on Sept. 26, 2025 protecting her operations.
The two orders appeared to conflict and left the District Magistrate unable to act on deficiencies he had found.
Lone also claimed the pump is less than 50 metres from his home and that its licence expired on Dec 31, 2025.
The court declined to rule on these points, leaving them to the district authorities.
The court directed that the penalty on IOCL stands.
The District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, will inquire whether the pump was installed at the sanctioned location with all required NOCs.
If the petitioner has complied, she may operate the pump, and any encroachment blocking the access road must be removed under the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002.
Once the access is built, the National Highway Authority must grant final permission and allow the pump to be energised.
If the inquiry finds deficiencies, she gets time to fix them. If she cannot, the pump is to be closed or sealed.





