Srinagar: On December 16, 1999, a medical board assessed a man’s age at 32, placing his birth around 1967. Guess what… this man had a son born on February 25, 1966!
The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh held on Monday that this mismatch, though a significant circumstance, does not amount to forgery because a certificate with false contents is not automatically a “false document”.
It also ruled that the Crime Branch can investigate the case even when corruption charges emerge during the probe.
Justice Sanjay Parihar partly allowed a petition by Dr Gulzar Ahmad, and Dr. Abdul Lateef Salik, who challenged FIR No. 64/2021.
Prosecutors say that the principal accused in the case, Ghulam Hassan Bhat used a false age certificate to secure regularization and permanent employment in the Public Health Engineering (PHE) department.
The certificate was issued by a Medical Board comprising the petitioner doctors and the then Chief Medical Officer, Srinagar, Dr Abdul Samad Sheikh, who died in 2012.
Records of Bhat’s son, a Forest Guard, showed his birth as 25.02.1966, while the Board’s assessment put the father’s birth around 1967.
Investigators alleged the doctors abused their positions to help Bhat draw salary and benefits from the exchequer.
The petitioners argued that only the Vigilance Organization, now the Anti-Corruption Bureau, could probe offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
The Crime Branch said the FIRs were first registered for cheating, forgery and conspiracy under the Ranbir Penal Code, and the corruption angle surfaced later.
The court rejected the exclusivity plea. It held that Section 3 of the Act does not give the Vigilance Organization exclusive jurisdiction, and that police officers of Deputy Superintendent rank or above, including those of the Crime Branch, can investigate such offences.
An administrative circular, it said, cannot curtail jurisdiction conferred by statute or notification.
Here the dates met the law. The court accepted that the certificate was not a “false document” under Section 464 of the Penal Code, since there was no allegation of forged signatures, fabricated seals, impersonation or unauthorized alteration.
The Board members were authorized to assess age. Even if the assessment of 1967 against the son’s 1966 birth was wrong, the court distinguished between the authenticity of a document’s execution and the truthfulness of its contents.
Charges under Sections 467, 468 and 471 were quashed.
The court said the father being assessed as born about a year after his son was “manifestly inconsistent” with the biological relationship, and of “considerable significance” in examining deliberate misrepresentation.
It held the allegation was not a mere error of judgment, and found sufficient prima facie material to continue proceedings under Sections 420 (cheating) and 120-B, read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, relating to criminal conspiracy.
Whether the assessment was deliberately manipulated is a matter for trial.
The agency may complete its investigation and file a final report, subject to statutory requirements, including sanction for prosecution, which is reportedly pending as the petitioners remain in service.


