• About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
Epaper
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Images - Latest News Update
No Result
View All Result
Home TOP NEWS

HC dismisses plea challenging Vaid’s appointment as DGP

Rashid Paul by Rashid Paul
May 17, 2018
in TOP NEWS
A A
0
HC dismisses plea challenging Vaid’s appointment as DGP
FacebookTwitterWhatsapp

Srinagar May 16: The J&K High Court on Wednesday dismissed a plea challenging the appointment of Dr S P Vaid as the top cop of the state by superseding his senior officer, S K Mishra.

Justices A M Magray and M K Hanjura while dismissing the petition by S K Mishra, managing director J&K Police Housing Corporation (a Post equivalent to Director General of Police – DGP) observed that seniority cannot be the basis for making appointment for the post of DGP for the state of J&K.

More News

Slain SPOs laid to rest with honours in Kishtwar; LG Sinha pays tributes

CAASPI delegation proposes social defence volunteer groups in J&K

CM chairs Cabinet meeting in Jammu; key proposals discussed

Load More

“The post of top cop is a selection post, the appointment to which is made amongst the officers holding the post of DGP as is made abundantly clear by Note 2 attached to Sub-rule 2 to Rule 3”, said the judges.

They added (even if, for the sake of argument, it is assumed, but not conceded, that it is a promotional post), it has to be promotion by selection for which seniority is not the sole criterion”.

The petitioner Mishra pleaded that he is the senior most Indian Police Service (IPS Officer) of J&K, belonging to the 85 batch, whereas S.P.Vaid, belongs to the 86 batch of IPS.

He also pleaded that Vaid had illegally superseded him by virtue of a government order which is contrary to the law.

He filed a petition before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh, challenging the vires of the order of the appointment of Vaid.

The Tribunal observed that there are no reasons, much less cogent, to interfere in the selection and appointment of Vaid as DGP of J&K.

Not finding favor with the judgment of the Tribunal Mishra filed a petition before the J&K Court. He sought directions for quashing the Tribunal’s decision, and prayed for appointment as the DGP of entire police force of the state.

At the core of his petition he challenged the state cabinet decision that had selected Vaid as the chief police officer of J&K.

The court held that the assessment of the merit and other relevant facts for making selection on the post of DGP was purely within the domain and jurisdiction of the state government.

It said since the petitioner was also considered in the panel of eligible officers by the cabinet, so he cannot challenge the validity of the order by which Vaid  had been selected and appointed as the DGP of J&K.

The court said, “It is not the seniority that holds the roost in making selection/ appointment of the Director General of Police, but the merit that has to prevail and has a binding force”.

“The post of the Director General of Police is a selection post, the appointment to which is made amongst the officers holding the post of Director General of Police as is made abundantly clear by Note 2 attached to Sub-rule 2 to Rule 3”, it said.

It stated “even if, for the sake of argument, it is assumed, but not conceded, that it is a promotional post, it has to be promotion by selection for which seniority is not the sole criterion”.

There are judicial precedents that lay down that the correctness of the reasons that prompted the government to take a decision and take one course of action instead of the other is not a matter of concern in the judicial review and the court is not the appropriate forum for conducting such investigations, it observed.

The scope of judicial review has to be confined to find out whether the Government decision was against the statutory provisions or violative of the fundamental rights of the citizens of the State, it said further.

The judges held that the courts have to be loath in interfering in the policy/ administrative decision taken by the Government unless it smacks of arbitrariness, or to put it in other words, that it is irrational and not circumspect or is wayward, aberrant, malicious and capricious, offending the basic requirement of Article 14 of the Constitutions of India.

Previous Post

MLAs who defect should be banned from contesting for 1 term: Omar

Next Post

Delhi decides to cease fire for Ramazan

Rashid Paul

Rashid Paul

Rashid Paul is  Associate Editor at Kashmir Images. He can be reached at rashidpaul@gmail.com

Related Posts

Slain SPOs laid to rest with honours in Kishtwar; LG Sinha pays tributes

Slain SPOs laid to rest with honours in Kishtwar; LG Sinha pays tributes
November 14, 2026

Kishtwar: Hundreds of people gathered in the remote Dachhan area of Kishtwar district on Friday to bid a tearful farewell...

Read moreDetails

CAASPI delegation proposes social defence volunteer groups in J&K

CAASPI delegation proposes social defence volunteer groups in J&K
November 14, 2026

Jammu: A delegation of the Centre for Activities for Advanced, Strong and Progressive India (CAASPI), Jammu and Kashmir, on Friday...

Read moreDetails

CM chairs Cabinet meeting in Jammu; key proposals discussed

CM chairs Cabinet meeting in Jammu; key proposals discussed
November 14, 2026

Jammu: Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on Friday chaired a meeting of the Council of Ministers here to deliberate on key...

Read moreDetails

Attack on CRPF post: Several suspects picked up for questioning

Searches intensified after Kathua attack; DGP reviews ongoing operation
November 14, 2026

Srinagar: Several suspects have been picked up for questioning in the aftermath of the Kulgam attack in which three CRPF...

Read moreDetails

BJP asks Pakistan to hand over PoK, says Kashmir integral part of India

Muslims will be looked after by the Modi govt: BJP leader Shahnawaz Hussain
November 14, 2026

New Delhi: The BJP on Friday asked Pakistan to hand over Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK) to India, asserting that Kashmir was,...

Read moreDetails

NC ready for any sacrifice in struggle for restoration of J&K’s rights: Farooq Abdullah

Jammu can finally look forward to comprehensive development under NC rule: Farooq Abdullah
November 14, 2026

Srinagar: National Conference president Farooq Abdullah on Friday said his party is ready to make any sacrifice in the struggle...

Read moreDetails
Next Post
Delhi decides to cease fire for Ramazan

Delhi decides to cease fire for Ramazan

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Our team
  • Terms of Service
E-Mailus: kashmirimages123@gmail.com

© 2025 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • CITY & TOWNS
  • LOCAL
  • BUSINESS
  • NATION
  • WORLD
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
    • ON HERITAGE
    • CREATIVE BEATS
    • INTERALIA
    • WIDE ANGLE
    • OTHER VIEW
    • ART SPACE
  • Photo Gallery
  • CARTOON
  • EPAPER

© 2025 Kashmir Images - Designed by GITS.