The Perils and Pitfalls of Proselytising
‘And therefore to reason together one must not start from any conclusion, from any belief, from any dogma which conditions the mind so that we cannot reason together.’
By: Dr Shabeer Ahmad Khan
Today, in Kashmir, a palpable tension permeates the air, one born of fervent religious proselytisation. This age-old practice, characterised by a relentless push and pull between competing belief systems, has gained renewed prominence in recent times, reflecting broader global trends of ideological polarisation and cultural strife. As we delve into this complex phenomenon, it becomes evident that beneath the surface lies a confluence of factors – from individual identity crises to societal marginalisation – that fuel the flames of religious fervour and exacerbate the inherent tensions within Kashmiri society.
At the heart of the matter lies a fundamental human impulse – the quest for meaning and belonging. In a region marked by historical tumult and geopolitical instability, religion often serves as both a refuge and a rallying cry for the dispossessed and marginalised. For many Kashmiris, particularly those who have experienced socioeconomic hardship or political disenfranchisement, religious adherence offers a sense of community and purpose in an otherwise tumultuous world. However, the irony is not lost on observers – that those who most fervently seek to proselytise others often do so from a place of personal insecurity or ignorance, grappling with their own existential dilemmas even as they seek to impose their beliefs on others.
Indeed, the landscape of religious proselytisation in Kashmir is rife with contradictions and complexities. On one hand, there are those who espouse rigid interpretations of Islam, such as Wahhabism or Deobandism, and seek to impose their views on others through coercion or indoctrination. These individuals, often driven by a sense of religious zealotry or ideological purity, are quick to condemn those who do not conform to their narrow worldview, viewing dissent as a threat to their own sense of identity and authority. On the other hand, there are those who, having experienced marginalisation or ostracisation in society, seek solace and validation in religious conversion, viewing it as a means of reclaiming agency and belonging in a world that has cast them aside.
The consequences of this relentless tug-of-war are manifold, extending far beyond the realm of individual belief to encompass broader social and political dynamics. In Kashmir, a region already beset by ethnic and religious tensions, the proliferation of competing religious ideologies has only served to exacerbate existing fault lines, fuelling sectarian strife and communal discord. Moreover, the politicisation of religion – whether by state actors or non-state actors – has further complicated the landscape, transforming religious identity into a potent tool of social control and manipulation.
In the face of such entrenched divisiveness, the imperative of reasoned discourse and critical inquiry becomes all the more pressing. As one Indian thinker so eloquently articulated, the act of thinking together – of engaging in thoughtful dialogue and reasoned debate – holds the key to transcending the limitations of dogma and ideology. It is only through open-mindedness and intellectual humility that we can hope to bridge the chasm of misunderstanding and mistrust that separates us from one another.
Yet, the challenges of fostering genuine dialogue and understanding in a climate of religious polarisation are not to be underestimated. Deep-seated prejudices and preconceptions, compounded by historical grievances and geopolitical rivalries, pose formidable barriers to meaningful engagement and reconciliation. Moreover, the pervasive influence of extremist ideologies – propagated through social media, religious institutions, and educational systems – serves to perpetuate a cycle of fear and distrust, further entrenching sectarian divisions and inhibiting genuine dialogue.
In this context, the role of education emerges as paramount in addressing the root causes of religious extremism and fanaticism. By promoting critical thinking skills and fostering a nuanced understanding of religious and philosophical traditions, educational institutions can empower individuals to navigate the complexities of identity and belief with wisdom and discernment. Moreover, by instilling values of empathy and tolerance, educators can help cultivate a culture of mutual respect and understanding, thereby laying the groundwork for a more inclusive and harmonious society.
Similarly, the importance of grassroots initiatives and community-led interventions cannot be overstated. By fostering interfaith dialogue and promoting collaboration across religious divides, local activists and civil society organisations can help mitigate the impact of religious extremism and promote a culture of coexistence and cooperation. Moreover, by amplifying the voices of moderate religious leaders and fostering alliances between religious communities, these initiatives can serve as fortifications against the tide of sectarianism and intolerance that threatens to engulf Kashmiri society.
The phenomenon of religious proselytisation in Kashmir, as elsewhere, underscores the urgent need for introspection and dialogue. By heeding the call to reason together, we can confront the challenges of identity and belief with courage and compassion, transcending the narrow confines of sectarianism and forging a path towards a more inclusive and harmonious future. In a world beset by division and discord, it is only through the power of reason and empathy that we can hope to build a brighter tomorrow for ourselves and for generations to come.
The writer has a PhD from AMU.
Kashmir Images is an English language daily newspaper published from Srinagar (J&K), India. The newspaper is one of the largest circulated English dailies of Kashmir and its hard copies reach every nook and corner of Kashmir Valley besides Jammu and Ladakh region.
